Every time I make a new Buddypoke avatar, I become immensely proud of my collection. Proud enough that I would probably post it here. But I wonder whether creative customization really counts as original artwork. I already have a few Demotivational and LOLcaption style deviations posted, and I feel a tad guilty every time they get a favorite (partially because they're often the only ones that do). While the creativity, humor, addition of text, and photo manipulation are all mine, the images being used to convey it are not.
And yet, there are artists who use things like stock images, pre-rendered photoshop brushes, and the like. There's some copyright law that states that a likeness altered by a mere 10% can be considered original content. Fonts are not something specifically created by the majority of artists that add text to images. I have seen fan art of copyrighted characters be promoted to the status of Daily Deviation on this very website. Where does one draw the line? At what point is borrowing elements okay?
Of course, I'm going to pretty ridiculous extremes here (MUST A PAINTER MIX HIS OWN PAINTS?), but that's the kind of guy I am. I have to know the limits of the rules. Guesswork makes me uneasy. Where some might say that a photo taken by another and then edited counts as an original work, others may not. Where some might say the use of a stock image is okay with given permission, some extremists (like myself) might question the artist for using someone else's art as a foundation for their own. An even greater extreme might suggest that photography is not a valid art form in general, as the photographer has not actually created anything but merely captured it from a particular angle.
Such is the dilemma surrounding my Buddypoke cosplays. I did not create the program, or the customizable options. In fact, I did not even create the characters I am attempting to replicate via a different medium. I merely had the idea to arrange those pre-rendered textures within the limits of a program in order to simulate the likenesses of familiar characters.
I was originally going to use this journal entry as a preface, and then link to an off-site collection of my questionably original work. But after having thought about it while writing this, I have managed to flesh out a reasonable justification I feel good about (as far as the Buddypokes are concerned), and will use that as my grounds for posting some of them here. I will also be going through my current Deviations and removing the ones I feel I do not deserve artistic credit for.
I still don't fully understand the boundaries and where to draw the lines on creativity and originality. I find it rather fun to think about. Feel free to share your thoughts on the subject, and whether you believe I have a right to post what I have posted.
EDIT: Deleted Deviations
Waffle Man
[link]Secret Identities
[link]With Super Size Fries
[link]